"Unbelievable Numbers" Says Former GE CEO Jack Welch; Another Look at Jobs Including Government Jobs and Self-Employment
Political charges flew on Friday following the unexpected drop in unemployment rate by three-tenths of a percent.
Former GE CEO Jack Welch led the way with a Tweet "Unbelievable jobs numbers..these Chicago guys will do anything..can't debate so change numbers".
In two of the last three months the unemployment rate fell solely because of people dropping out of the labor force. This past month, people came back in the labor force but part-time hiring and government hiring went up even more.
Parttime employment went up by 582,000 as noted in my report September Jobs +114,000; Unemployment Rate 7.8%; Part-Time Workers +582,000; Initial Reaction and Election Impact.
Government hiring went up by 187,000 in September, something I failed to mention yesterday.
Household Data Detail
click on chart for sharper image
Taking a closer look, seasonally-adjusted, the number of government workers went up by 681,000 since June. (20.619 million in September vs. 19.938 million at the June low point). That's a lot of jobs (and jobs the economy can do without in my opinion).
Also note that self-employment rose in the last month by 118,000. How much of that number is trinket selling on Ebay or other self-employment with no real income?
Regardless, unless the BLS changed its survey methods or survey questions, as wild as the numbers seem, charges of political pandering are likely to be misguided.
Did the BLS make adjustments to how it asked questions? If so, someone would probably have spilled the beans already.
Summary Items of Note (Numbers May Overlap)
- Self-Employment +118,000
- Government +187,000
- Part-Time +582,000
This was not as strong a report as it first looked, whether one considers it "unbelievable" or not.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock